New rules for Detroit demolitions designed to protect public health
Detroit is in the middle of one of the most ambitious demolition campaigns the nation has ever seen, tearing down about 200 houses every week.
Many of the homes being razed are in neighborhoods where people still live. So Detroit officials sat down before the blitz to come up with some new regulations designed to keep people safe from dust, and from hazardous materials that could be in that dust – like lead, or asbestos.
“Normally I feel like environmental concerns and public health concerns are so reactionary,” said Regina Royan, an epidemiologist with Detroit’s health department who helped develop the new rules. “You bring in someone from the EPA after something goes wrong. You bring in a public health professional after something goes wrong.”
And that right there – a public health expert helping write rules for tearing down homes – is at the heart of what Detroit is doing differently.
Informed neighbors, accountable contractors
On a recent day on Heyden Street, in northwest Detroit, crews are taking down three homes. But a lot of work was done before getting to this point. Neighbors got a heads up that the crews would be coming. That’s something that didn’t used to happen regularly.
There are now field liaisons checking to make sure the contractors are following the rules, and fielding questions or complaints from neighbors. The people working on the demolitions are all required to wear bright green vests to ID them, with a phone number on the back that residents can call to get questions answered, or to report any problems.
Another new mandate is that crews have to spray down the houses as they’re coming down.
MCM Management is one of the main demolition contractors. Program manager Eric Dovas points to a machine that’s shooting a fine spray of water onto the house. He calls it “the dustbuster.”
“And it’s kind of like a snow-making machine, but it’s not freezing it,” Dovas says. “We also have a water truck over there.”
The point of the water is to keep the dust down. There’s a lot of respiratory disease in Detroit – asthma among kids – and the dust could contain lead. That carries a whole other set of problems for children, ranging from learning disabilities and behavior problems to kidney damage.
An unprecedented effort
City officials say the unprecedented scale of Detroit’s blight problem demanded a different approach. A report in May put the number of blighted buildings in Detroit at more than 40,000. And it said there’s another 38,000 vacant or foreclosed homes.
“Large-scale residential demolitions pose considerable environmental challenges,” the EPA said in a statement. “Poorly-managed demolitions can leave an unnecessary environmental, economic, and social legacy for community residents and hinder future redevelopment.”
City officials worked with the EPA and state regulators to develop the new standards. Detroit Building Authority Director David Manardo said it’s not clear yet how much cost these extra regulations add, but he added that even if it is marginally more expensive, it’s a good deal if it avoids problems in the long run.
“Advising residents on demolition activity can help them take steps to reduce their exposure to contaminants or dust,” said the EPA. “Detroit’s new demolition practices now balance speed, cost, and environmental performance. These practices may be applicable to other communities."
On Seneca Street on Detroit’s east side, Olivia Johnson watched an excavator scoop up piles of debris from the house that used to stand next door to hers. She said she was glad when she found out the house would be razed, but she did have some concerns.
“Because the older homes have asbestos,” Johnson said. But she said the demolition crews “were very, very cautious about that, and they did have the water, and I’m happy about that.”
Johnson watched as a large truck was loaded up with debris. The city’s new rules require that the loads get covered. That’s another safeguard against contaminated dust floating through the neighborhood.
“This effort is the largest municipal redevelopment strategy in the country, maybe the world,” said epidemiologist Regina Royan. ”When you think about these extra environmental and public health concerns, why not address these up front?”
Here's a video produced by the contractor MCM Management that shows the demolition process, start to finish: