Commenters oppose new Line 5 anchor supports, accuse state of ignoring concerns
The Michigan Department of Environmental Quality held a public hearing on Wednesday evening in Mackinaw City, taking comments on proposed new anchor supports for the Line 5 oil pipelines.
About 60 people showed up, including concerned local residents, members of Michigan indigenous communities, and local environmental groups.
Commenters spoke for about two and a half hours. Every speaker was opposed to permitting the work.
Enbridge Energy has applied for a permit to add 48 more anchor supports securing the twin oil pipelines to the lakebed under the Straits of Mackinac.
Enbridge started installing anchor supports in 2002 to deal with the problem of lakebed erosion. Strong currents in the Straits have washed out sections of the bottom in the past, leaving long spans of pipeline unsupported. Enbridge's easement with the state of Michigan requires there be no unsupported spans of pipeline longer than 75 feet.
Enbridge treats the installations as pipeline maintenance, which means any environmental impact assessment is restricted to areas immediately surrounding the supports.
Opponents say the addition of anchor supports amounts to a full redesign of the pipeline and should go through the same, more rigorous, permit process. Leonard Page is the chair of the Straits of Mackinac Alliance, a local environmental organization. He says the new supports shouldn't be looked at individually.
“It’s like missing the forest for the trees," he says. "With now almost 200 of these anchor supports, that’s 400 anchor screws. This is a new structure.”
The Grand Traverse Bay Band of Ottawa and Chippewa Indians has filed a petition challenging a permit for 22 anchor supports approved earlier this year. The Straits of Mackinac Alliance has filed a similar petition.
Many people who spoke recalled a similar meeting last year about the previously approved anchors and were angry with the DEQ, accusing officials of not listening. Lynn Fraze, a local resident and member of the Straits Area Concerned Citizens for Peace, Justice and the Environment, called the public comment hearings a farce.
“Basically [Gov. Rick] Snyder and [Attorney General Bill] Schuette go behind closed doors with Enbridge and do whatever they want," she said. "But we’re not gonna give up. We’re not gonna stop coming to these meetings.”
In addition to being opposed to new anchor supports, most commenters wanted Line 5 shut down altogether.
Public comments can be made using the DEQ’s website until July 22.
Editor's note: Enbridge Energy is one of Michigan Radio's corporate sponsors.