The Making Of Apollo's Command Module: 2 Engineers Recall Tragedy And Triumph | Michigan Radio
WUOMFM

The Making Of Apollo's Command Module: 2 Engineers Recall Tragedy And Triumph

Originally published on July 20, 2019 5:23 pm

Look at a picture of the Apollo 11 launch and you'll probably notice the rocket's pointed tip and the fire coming from the five giant engines in the first stage of the 36-story-tall Saturn V rocket.

What you might miss is arguably the most important part of the entire thing: the command module.

It's the tiny, gumdrop-shaped vehicle sitting just below the tip. It holds the astronauts, their clothing, sleeping bags, food and — along with a companion service module — all of the systems needed for a round-trip journey to the moon. It's also the only piece of the spacecraft to complete the entire trip and splash down back on Earth.

(Left) The Apollo 11 command and service modules are mated to the Saturn V lunar module adapter. (Right) The Apollo 11 spacecraft command module is loaded aboard a Super Guppy aircraft at Ellington Air Force Base for shipment to North American Rockwell Corp.
NASA

"It was the boat that basically got people there," said Bill Barry, NASA's chief historian. "A mission to the moon wouldn't have happened without a command module."

"A lot of chaos"

The command module was born at North American Aviation in Downey, Calif., after the company was awarded the contract in November 1961.

What used to be farmland just south of Los Angeles was transformed over the 1950s and '60s, into one of the premier places for aerospace testing and design, with a major period of expansion owed to the Apollo program.

President John F. Kennedy's 1961 challenge to put an American on the moon by the end of the decade meant North American was under a severe time crunch. So, it began hiring engineers and technicians. Lots of them. From all over the country.

"When I first arrived in California and reported for work, there was a lot of chaos," said Chuck Lowry, an expert in parachutes, which were vital for slowing the command module's descent as it returned to Earth.

He moved his pregnant wife and two young kids away from a good home with family and friends in Ohio, straight into a motel in Downey, where they lived for the first three weeks so that he could get started working right away.

"Many people came in and there was just no room for them," Lowry said. The hiring ramped up so quickly that the contractor ran out of drafting tables. "I know people that took doors off of the offices and put them on sawhorses and that became their drafting table," he said.

After a while, things began to settle and a system established itself, which meant that the folks on the ground in Downey were working out the details and beginning tests of the conical module.

Chuck Lowry (left) reviews designs on a drafting board with Carlos Moore and Kel Shaw (right).
Courtesy of Chuck Lowry

That included crawling in and out of the roughly Volkswagen Beetle-sized capsule, sometimes with five other people doing their jobs in there at the same time. Gerald Blackburn remembers how tight it was. He was only 19 when he started on the project as a lab technician, testing and inspecting hardware.

If a bolt needed to be moved half an inch, Blackburn said, there'd be endless meetings about it and production could be delayed.

"You got to the point where you began to realize that this thing was so complex. It was so big that there was no way you could fathom the whole program," he said. "So you had to rely on everybody who was doing their job and taking care of what they needed to take care of."

"You learn very quickly that there was a lot we didn't know about building spacecraft," he added.

For Lowry and Blackburn, Apollo was their lives. Working nonstop, 10-15 hours a day at times and rarely seeing their families.

Still, both men speak of the time fondly, reminiscing about what it was like to be driven by the purpose of one common goal and how, in the beginning, those feelings were amplified by a sort of naive optimism.

Gerald Blackburn at the Columbia Memorial Space Center in Downey, Calif., on July 2.
Michael Hernandez for NPR

The day everything changed

It's not that people didn't think something could go wrong, it's just that before Jan. 27, 1967, nothing major had. Certainly, nothing on such a catastrophic scale.

During a routine launch rehearsal test of what was scheduled to be the first manned Apollo mission, a spark set off an all-consuming fire in the pure oxygen environment of the module. The hatch couldn't be opened quickly enough and the cockpit, full of flammable materials, was quickly engulfed. The three astronauts inside were killed.

Back in Downey, production came to a halt while the fire was investigated, which took months.

"Everybody that was working here, without knowing what the results of the investigation are, are asking themselves the same question, 'Did I do something wrong?'" said Blackburn. "The whole tone had changed."

"Our feeling about the lunar mission took on a whole new dimension of increased safety," said Lowry. "I think in the beginning, before the fire, before 1967, we were very pressed by schedule. We did everything to meet schedules. And when you do that, you're apt to miss details that could be very important. You don't know it at the time."

Lowry said safety boards were set up, inviting additional scrutiny of Apollo designs from outside experts. They made sure they could trace every little piece of the module, who manufactured it and what it was made of, down to the nuts and bolts.

Chuck Lowry keeps Apollo memorabilia, both old and new, in his home. (Left) Lowry adjusts a cap commemorating the 50th anniversary of Apollo 11. (Right) Lowry holds a model of a prototype command module.
Michael Hernandez for NPR

The module design was overhauled, including the addition of a quick-open door to allow the astronauts to exit the capsule in case of emergency.

North American's Space and Information Systems Division president, Harrison Storms, was removed.

But it wasn't long until the ruthless pace of the program picked back up.

"As John F. Kennedy said, 'we're going to land and return men safely in the 1960s.' In that decade. And we held that goal very sacred. And it was important, because you've got Congress, you've got people, the world watching. We just have to meet our goal on that," said Blackburn.

A turning point

In 1968, there was another turning point. Two, in fact.

And they were both good.

Apollo 7, the first crewed mission, made its way to space. The command module performed so well that NASA felt confident in making a bold move — sending Apollo 8 all the way around the moon in December.

Apollo 9 was an Earth-orbit test of the lunar module. Apollo 10 was a "dress rehearsal" for the first landing, with astronauts descending to less than 50,000 feet above the lunar surface before returning home.

And then, the historic mission.

While Buzz Aldrin and Neil Armstrong visited the moon's surface, Michael Collins flew the command and service module around the moon before meeting back up with them and heading home.

Lowry listened in from Downey to the radio chatter between Mission Control and the Apollo 11 crew in space.

"[You would] always listen like, 'is there anything in the conversation going on that might indicate something is wrong?'" he said. "[It's] kind of intense. ... you're just wanting them to get back home safely."

On their way back, the astronauts sent one final transmission from space.

Collins had this to say: "This operation is somewhat like the periscope of a submarine. All you see is the three of us, but beneath the surface are thousands and thousands of others. And to all of them, I'd like to say thank you very much."

YouTube

Our cosmic Camelot

Upon reentry, Lowry's parachutes deployed and inflated, and all of Blackburn's quality testing paid off. The capsule splashed down in the North Pacific and the astronauts made it back safely.

More than 400,000 people worked on the Apollo program.

"John F. Kennedy had said, 'We're going to the moon not because it's easy, but because it's hard.' And he was right on that," said Lowry. "It took a lot of years. We worked a lot of weekends, a lot of holidays. ...Our families suffered. There were a lot of heart attacks and broken homes and strokes. Apollo took a toll."

The Apollo 11 command module splashed down on July 24, 1969. (Left) A helicopter hovers over the inverted command module shortly after splashdown. (Right) Astronauts Neil Armstrong, Michael Collins and Buzz Aldrin await pickup from their life raft.
NASA

Lowry basically didn't see his family for a decade. Blackburn, who rose to the ranks of management at North American, lost an eye in an accident when a pressure gauge exploded during a test of command module components.

Still, he said, "I've referred to what I call this place and that time as our cosmic Camelot. ...When people and a country came together with commitment. A commitment to do something and achieve a goal that was incredible."

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

SARAH MCCAMMON, HOST:

Thousands of people contributed to the effort to get Buzz Aldrin, Neil Armstrong and Michael Collins to the moon, which happened 50 years ago today. The only part of the actual spacecraft to make it to the moon and back was the tiny, gumdrop-shaped capsule perched right at the tip. It carried the astronauts with all of their life support and scientific resources crammed inside. It's called the Columbia Command Module. KPCC's Jacob Margolis spoke with two people who dedicated a decade to working on the capsule.

JACOB MARGOLIS, BYLINE: The module was born at North American Aviation in Downey, Calif., what used to be farmland just south of Los Angeles. John F. Kennedy's 1961 decree that we'd reach the moon by the end of the decade meant that an awful lot of people uprooted their lives and flooded in from across the country.

CHUCK LOWRY: When I first arrived in California and reported for work, there was a lot of chaos.

MARGOLIS: Chuck Lowry was an engineer whose job was in part to make sure the parachutes worked. He moved his pregnant wife and two young kids away from a good life with family and friends in Ohio to a motel in Downey so he could get started right away.

LOWRY: Many people came in, and there was just no room for them. We had people in the halls. We had people that needed a drafting table, and we ran out of them. And I know people that took doors off the offices and put them on sawhorses, and that became their drafting table. But after a while, we began to get things put together.

MARGOLIS: The command module had to have everything, from life support systems to seating to navigation to those parachutes to keep it from slamming into the ocean and killing the astronauts. While some designs would come from NASA, it was the folks on the ground in Downey who were working out the details.

Gerald Blackburn was from nearby. He was 19 when he started on the project as a lab technician.

GERALD BLACKBURN: Think of the Volkswagen Beetle. That's about the size of the command module interior with the seats out and everything, OK?

MARGOLIS: He says he was crawling in and out of it, testing things and installing nuts and bolts and tubing that had to be put in exactly the right place, sometimes with five other people doing their jobs in there, too. The capsule had to be as fine-tuned as a Swiss watch but as robust as a tank. And if a bolt needed to be moved half an inch, Jerry says, there'd be endless meetings about it, and production could be delayed.

BLACKBURN: You got to the point where you began to realize that this thing was so complex, it was so big that there was no way that you could fathom the whole program. So you had to rely on that everybody is doing their job and taking care of what they need to take care of.

MARGOLIS: Apollo was their lives, working 10 to 15 hour days, never seeing their families. In the beginning, there seemed to be this almost naive optimism, this gung-ho we're going to the moon, this is our mission sort of stuff. And then, on January 27, 1967, everything changed.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MIKE WALLACE: America's first three Apollo astronauts were trapped and killed by a flash fire that swept their moon ship early tonight during a launch pad test at Cape Kennedy in Florida.

MARGOLIS: A spark set off a huge fire the 100% oxygen environment in the capsule. The door couldn't be opened fast enough. The astronauts didn't have any sort of fireproofing on their suits. Jerry says it was terrible.

BLACKBURN: Everybody that was working here are asking themselves the same question - did I do something wrong?

MARGOLIS: There was an investigation.

BLACKBURN: The whole tone had changed.

MARGOLIS: Division president Harrison Storms was removed. They redesigned the capsule. New safety procedures were put into place. After a break, Chuck says, the ruthless pace of the program picked back up.

LOWRY: As John F. Kennedy said, we're going to land and return men safely in the 1960s, in that decade. And we held that goal very sacred, and it was important because you've got Congress, you've got people, you've got the world watching. And we'd just have to meet our goal on that.

MARGOLIS: Chuck says that another turning point - this a majorly positive one - was in 1968, when Apollo 7, the first crewed mission, made its way to space. Then Apollo 8 circled the moon. Nine, 10 - all good. The whole time, they're building more capsules, refining their designs, until, finally, 11.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

NEIL ARMSTRONG: Houston, the Eagle has landed.

MARGOLIS: Michael Collins flew the capsule around the moon while Buzz Aldrin and Neil Armstrong did their thing. Chuck recalls the joy and the fear.

LOWRY: On my shift, we would sit there in that control room and listen to the voice between the astronaut and ground control. And you always listened, like, is there anything in the conversation going on that might indicate something is wrong in anywhere or in your system? So it's kind of intense.

MARGOLIS: On their way back, the astronauts sent one final transmission from space. Collins had this to say.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MICHAEL COLLINS: This operation is somewhat like the periscope of a submarine. All you see is the three of us, but beneath the surface are thousands and thousands of others. And to all those, I would like to say, thank you very much.

MARGOLIS: Upon re-entry Chuck Lowry's parachutes deployed and inflated. All of Gerald Blackburn's quality testing paid off. The capsule floated down, and the astronauts returned to Earth safely. By the end of it, more than 400,000 people had worked on the Apollo program.

LOWRY: John F. Kennedy had said we're going to the moon not because it's easy but because it's hard. And he was right on that. It took a lot of years, and we worked a lot of weekends and holidays. And we worked hard. Our families suffered. There were a lot of heart attacks and broken homes and strokes. And Apollo took a toll.

MARGOLIS: Chuck basically didn't see his family for a decade. Jerry, who ended up as management eventually, actually lost an eye in an accident. Still, he says...

BLACKBURN: I refer to what I call this place and that time as our cosmic Camelot - a time when people in a country came together with a commitment to do something and to achieve a goal that was incredible.

MARGOLIS: For NPR News, I'm Jacob Margolis. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Tags: